Secure assessment
Assuring student learning requires the careful use of ‘secure’ assessment types at key points in the curriculum. Secure assessment types are those for which we can have high confidence that assessment rules were followed and can verify that the student completed the task. This is in contrast to ‘open’ assessments where rules may be more easily circumvented.
Open assessment types remain critical to students’ learning and will continue to be a significant part of our assessment mix. Students who genuinely engage with these tasks can benefit greatly from the opportunities they provide to develop essential knowledge, skills and competencies. They also provide an important mechanism for staff to provide students with feedback on how their understanding is developing.
This page collates advice on secure assessment to support the implementation of the University’s assessment principles that require 50 per cent of assessment within a subject is secure, unless a programmatic approach to assessment is taken to assuring learning.
This guide will continue to evolve as new forms of secure assessment are tested and developed. Work is under way across the University to build best-practice advice and case studies that demonstrate the use of secure assessment in all disciplines.
Secure assessment types and forms
Almost all secure assessment approaches rely on some form of observation of students while they are completing their assessment task. Observation of activities in-person is the most secure. If they are to be used, online observation tools (eg. proctoring tools) need to be very carefully chosen and tested to assure their security and combined with well-considered assessment tasks.
Five broad types of assessment are currently considered secure. Within each type, different disciplines may use a variety of tasks or activities. For most of these, the ways in which the conditions, assessment task and intended learning outcomes are designed will all impact their security, both in relation to GenAI misuse and other forms of academic misconduct. A short description of each of these categories is below, including a starting set of example activities.
Observed exam or test
Time-bound tasks with previously unseen questions or material. Includes practical exams, objective structured clinical examination, invigilated written exams and mid-semester tests or quizzes.
Learn moreInteractive oral assessment
Students engage with staff in dialogue about their work. Includes design and research project presentations, oral exams/vivas, moots, folio presentations.
Learn morePerformance
Students demonstrate mastery of technical skills, creativity and interpretation. Includes dramatic and musical performances and rehearsals.
Learn moreObserved internship or placement
Students are supervised and assessed in the workplace.
Learn moreSupervised student projects
Students demonstrate learning by completing a substantial project under sustained, structured supervision (including formative checks and feedback).
Learn moreContinuing work
The University is actively considering other options for secure assessment types, including combining assessments and asynchronous digital observation. These both require further work before they can be used as secure assessment options.